Skip to main content

'The Singer' fails to express Nubian blues

Many Nubians are finding fault with a Ramadan TV series they say misrepresents their forced displacement more than half a century ago.

nasser.jpg
A Nubian child is seen carrying a picture of Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser in episode five of Mohamed Mounir's "The Singer." The Ramadan series has been criticized by Nubians for misrepresenting their 1963 displacement from their homes for the construction of the Aswan High Dam. — YouTube.com/Alhayah Series TV

After episode five of Mohamed Mounir’s "The Singer" series aired recently, Nubians were angered by what they deemed to be misrepresentations of their displacement from their homes in 1963 to accommodate construction of the Aswan High Dam under President Gamal Abdel Nasser.

The Nubian page on Facebook categorically rejected the scenes, which it said inaccurately represented Nubians’ displacement and showed them as happy to leave their homes. In one scene, a child holds Abdel Nasser’s picture while in the background plays a song Nubians usually listen to on happy occasions.

The page launched a campaign against the series as it expressed its disappointment and said it had expected the series to highlight many Nubian issues, but this has not happened.

Nubian activist Hamdi Suleiman said the series constitutes a threat to Nubian tenets and intentionally misrepresents historical facts.

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE

Continue reading this exclusive analysis

Original reporting and analysis unavailable elsewhere. Subscribe to AL-MONITOR to read this story and access everything we publish