Skip to main content

The Kerry Talks: Blood, Sweat, Tears and Martin Indyk

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian Chairman Abu Mazen must each realize that the other side is unable to fulfill the expected demands.

Vice president and director of the Foreign Policy Program at the Brookings Institution in Washington D.C. , Martin Indyk, speaks during the U.S.- Islamic World Forum in Doha June 9, 2013. REUTERS/Mohammed Dabbous (QATAR - Tags: RELIGION) - RTX10HPL
Martin Indyk, vice president and director of the Foreign Policy Program at the Brookings Institution in Washington, speaks during the US-Islamic World Forum in Doha, June 9, 2013. — REUTERS/Mohammed Dabbous

The negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians were born in a breech position following a traumatic pregnancy with innumerable obstacles and problems along the way. The signs are not encouraging, indicating that the newborn suffers from very serious genetic defects. The baby is currently in the neonatal ICU connected to a respirator. Professor John Kerry stands at the side of the bassinet and prays.

Even if they survive, the life expectancy of these negotiations is short, difficult and frustrating. The odds that they will grow, to accomplish "mitzvot and good deeds," as they say in the Jewish tradition, are not great. We all need a miracle or somebody with especially creative thinking.

The sides are so far apart on the issues that it is difficult for them to reach even the most basic of agreements. For example, the identity of the new US representative on Israeli-Palestinian Peace talks, the person who will need to roll up his sleeves, dip his hand into the cesspools and try to fix the plumbing. The two names being heard in Washington are Dennis Ross and Martin Indyk.

Another name has been just added to the list of candidates for the post of American envoy — former ambassador Daniel Kurtzer, who served as the American ambassador to Israel. The decision is yet to be made, and all options are still open.  

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE

Continue reading this exclusive analysis

Original reporting and analysis unavailable elsewhere. Subscribe to AL-MONITOR to read this story and access everything we publish